Hostage-Taking: From ASG to PNP, One Big SNAFU

For a country that has bore the brunt of natural disasters and man-made disasters, economic malaise, a chronic insurgency, migration of professionals, dysfunctional government, human rights violations, sex scandals, botox for teens – the recent hostage taking was supposed to be just another day in these darn crazy islands. However – it isn’t. With foreign citizens – tourists and China involved – Aquino better sit up and take notice. Pinoys still put up with his BS – am not sure if the international community will. Don’t be mad if Chip Tsao or people from Hong Kong uses “Nation of Hostage Takers” next time around – we have it coming.

Hostage-taking is never justified and I join the voices of the civilized world which condemn and disapprove of such a violent act. I also join the people of Hong Kong in this moment of loss.

Haven’t we learned from our previous hostage-taking experiences?

These would have been another one of those “what else is new” thingie about the Philippines considering that for several years now the Philippines has had some high profile hostage taking incidences.

  • Disgruntled former ATO chief takes over NAIA air traffic control tower – Sunstar reported that Panfilo Villaruel, the head of the Philippine Air Transportation Office in the 1990’s and a transportation department assistant secretary during the term of former president Fidel V. Ramos, was killed with his aide, navy lieutenant Ricardo Gatcheliar, after aviation police stormed the tower at 3 a.m. and regained control of it about 30 minutes later, said Aviation Security Group Senior Superintendent Andres Caro. Radio station dzBB managed to interview Villaruel before the gunfight. Villaruel said the takeover was not an attempt to grab power but was an act of protest over the prevailing political and socio-economic situation in the Philippines. “This is my last contribution, my legacy to the decent people of the Philippines — to stand up and tell the leaders of this country to wake up,” he said.
  • 26 kids, 4 tutors freed as hostage crisis ends – The Inquirer reported that at least 26 school children and four teachers who were held hostage inside a bus in Manila for almost 10 hours Wednesday were freed by their armed captors who have surrendered to police. Armando Ducat Jr., the alleged leader, had agreed to release his captives at 7 p.m. following day-long negotiations with police. One of his two accomplices has been identified as Ogie Carbonel.Before Ducat released his hostages, he asked the public to light a candle and pray for all candidates in the upcoming elections that they might be “enlightened” so that they would not be corrupt.
  • Rescue raid ends in hostage deaths – CNN reported that ” A Philippine commando raid meant to free two Americans and a Philippine citizen held hostage by the Islamic rebel group Abu Sayyaf ended with two of the hostages dead Friday.”
  • Blast from past: Killing of Gens. Batalla, Bautista– The Inquirer wrote that on Jan. 5, 1989, Brig. Gen. Eduardo Batalla, then commander of the Philippine Constabulary in Western Mindanao, and his chief of staff Col. Romeo Abendan, along with five other people, were taken hostage by discharged policemen and soldiers in Batalla’s own office at the Recom-9 headquarters in Cawa-Cawa, Zamboanga City. The hostage-takers were led by rogue cop Rizal Alih, who, along with the group numbering about seven, had been ordered to report to Batalla’s office in connection with the killing of seven persons in 1984.

Thus, given this quite recent string of hostage taking incidences, one would think that the PNP had its act together.  Banging the bus windows wasn’t exactly my idea of a well oiled act.

As Gracie Burnham wrote “The AFP wanted to help us hostages, but pulling off an operation that sensitive was simply beyond their training,” she writes in her book. “At this point, we knew that our only real hope of getting out alive lay instead in negotiation. And for the Abu Sayyaf, negotiation meant only one thing: ransom money.”

What happened to all these hostage-taking reviews?

You would expect that hostage management protocols were updated to reflect the new lessons learned. That negotatiors will be more skilled. That there will be negotiators. That tactics will be upgraded. But then, it’s the Philippines – where it is too much to ask for things to improve. Where demanding that things be improved is called “whining”.

Very well then – take some tips from the NYPD!

What is non releasable information?

  • Information posing an undue risk to the personal safety of members of the Department, media representatives, victims or others.
  • Information that may interfere with police operations.
  • Information that adversely affects the rights of an accused or the investigation or prosecution of a crime.
  • Information concerning the identity of children under 16 years of age who are complainants or arrested except when arrested for a crime which would classify them as a Juvenile Offender
  • Information concerning the victim of a sex crime.

Though of course, I wouldn’t be surprised with another cop-out – “But that’s NYPD – this is the Philippines” 👿

Seriously, when I started going through a checklist – someone said it was “whining”. Sheesh, no wonder pinoys never learn because of self-appointed “konsensya” who will tell you not to be inquisitive because it is called “whining”. Frankly, I couldn’t care any less whether it’s called whining or not. The point of the matter is do you want to get to the bottom of this or not. Or do you just want to put up an act of getting to the bottom of it – puro palabas at kaplastikan. 👿

Come to think of it when grievances are called “whining” and just shoved under the carpet – stuff happens. Stuff can be all over the ceiling, on the wall, on the streets – it can be your gray matter splattered being washed into the sewers of Manila. ❗

So as the mainstream media will go into its ritual of whodunnit, whydunnit, howdunnit. The Government and Congress will do another ceremonial review – just like they did with Ondoy. But – don’t ask whether the review led to remedial measures and whether the actions were implemented completely – because frankly you’ll get the look of deer staring at the headlights.

The Big Picture

We need to go further past the individual circumstances of where decorated police officers turn “rogue” and ask the question – what sort of pressures will turn battle hardened men and make them snap.

With Rizal Alih and Mendoza – it was a desire to retain their jobs and keep the authority and powers which the job provided. With Villaruel and Ducat – it was about the sorry state of the Philippines. The death of Martin Burnham was all about money for ASG.

It’s all about economics! And what is the Philippines doing about it? Your guess is as good as mine.

Mendoza is just the beginning.

Remember those AFP officers whose grievances and promotions were swept under the carpet by Mr Aquino’s allies in the AFP? High rates of electricity, water, telephone, tollway fees – Coup coup ru coup coup deja vu :mrgreen:



  1. lakambini · ·

    More more coups! More coups than Cory’s reign. Idol si Nanay kasi.

  2. mga ulol · ·

    So what else is new, mga ulol. Hostage-taking, kidnap for ransom (KFR), rido, salvage for hire, magnanakaw kabi-kabila, mangdurugas, et al. It is just another day in paradise. Mga ulol! :mrgreen:

  3. Its very scary situation in the PH…the loot by mafia families who control the economy are pushing ordinary PH to the brink of violence. What a man got to do, if he has nothing to loose, the government did a stupid thing by not giving his retirement benefits…Mendosa was supposed to retire next year.
    What would he do, with no pension money after work….to top that…during negotiations..the government refused his reinstatement  ..atleast they could have told him..his pension is restored…they did not do that either…agreed..he was a bad man..however, in the current situation better option could have been used to save lifes.

  4. From a report in the Australian newspaper The Age:

    ===start of quote

    “A large group of police failed to get into the bus after surrounding the vehicle for nearly half an hour,” the Hong Kong Economic Journal said.

    “Their appalling professional standards, and the lack of strategic planning, made observers both angry and sad. This tragedy could have been avoided.”

    ===end of quote

    Indeed, could have been avoided if not for our renowned bahala na and pwede na yan mentalities.

  5. Kidnapping in the Philippines is making a school already. The authorities, the media and the people should learn from these tragedies. We have to address the roots of crimes in this country, that is poverty.

    Control the population, open the market, change the system of government, get rid of protectionism clauses in the constitution, etc. The lawmakers must start discussing on relevant issues for the betterment of this society. They must refrain from wasting time investigating past issues and delegate those to proper venues.

  6. Netornit · ·

    It’s like the elections all over again,only worse.

  7. this is just a result of the elections – choose an oligarch – and it will be more of the same – i hate to say I told you so – specially when things become bloody – but hey.. brace yourselves – you are not over the first year of Aquino – yet

  8. ako ang simula ng pagkabobo · ·

    may mga tao pala na tinatawag na imperialist ang getreal movement, lalo na sa population control.

    Nabasa ko lang sa mga archieves ng GRP.

    Mukhang mahirap itong laban na ito.


    Tunay nga bang ABNOY si Noynoy?

  9. I can smell chaos brewing… I’d better get my Frappuchino ready to witness the Chaos beginning!

    Now I really wish that the world will end in 2012…

  10. Why not an Earl Grey as the zerg-esque lowlife that are the primary component of the Yellow Horde are burned by the purifying beam called reality? At this rate, the Day of Wrath will probably come sooner.

  11. Hyden Toro · ·

    When hostage takers are the armed agents of the law…you have a serious situation in the country. The imbecile President Noynoy Aquino; should take notice. This is where good and strong leadership are needed and manifested. To Hide somewhere in a Toilet; to make yourself, not to be contacted by anybody. Shows: immature and wavering leadership. Why did President Noynoy Aquino, refuse to brief the Governor of Hong Kong, during the hostage negotiation incident? Is he afraid? Maybe his Depression, kicked in. He went to take on his medications. He cannot stand the incident. He does not know what to do…So long as there will be disgruntled men in uniform; desperate, because, they have been given the end of the rope. There will be Other Hostage Situations. We need Psychologists and Psychiatrists, I think, in the Armed Forces. These people are armed; then, they become Nut Basket Cases…And, the idiotic Media is willing to cover, the idiotic incidents, to booast their Ratings. The whole country is a Nut Case, begining with its President…

  12. This is only within the first two months! It’s already hell! Nice!


    Ang may KASALANAN nitong lahat ay ang OMBUDSWOMAN na si M. Guitterrez . Siya ang dapat sisihin talaga ng mga nagrereklamo diyan.

  14. Siya lang?

    Sobrang kitid ng ganung pag-iisip.

    Eh paano ang mga administrator ng PNP who do not fight for good salaries for our policemen? What about the media who showed the hostage taker on TV what was happening to his brother and how the police were “sneaking” up on him? Paano si Presidente na nagtago sa opisina niya at iniwasan ang Chinese ambassador?

  15. silvercrest · ·

    Pnoy did say,”Kayo ang boss ko.”, to the NoyPs

    He never mentioned Hong Kong nationals.

    So absuelto daw siya…not my job!

  16. @JuandelaCruz

    Baka nga si Ombudsman Gutierrez ang dahilan kung bakit di nakialam si PNoy. Baka gusto niyang isalang sa apoy at mabigo si Ombudsman para masabi niya na magbitiw ito sa puwesto kung sakaling magkamali ang desisyon. Kaya siguro nakakainsulto ang ngiti ng Presidente, akala niya si Ombudsman Gutierrez nga lang ang sisisihin. Baka di niya akalain na pati siya – damay!

  17. maligalig · ·

    ‘king ina! na expose na naman kabobohan ni noynoy sa HK hostage na punyetang massacre na yan. nang matapos ang lahat, tsaka sisisihin ang media kung bakit DAW nagkaroon ng leak, syempre sa loob ng tourist bus mayroon radyo at telebisyon. eh si engot na presidente? ano ginawa maghapon? nanood ng TV!? hindi man lang dumampot ng telepono at sabihin sa pulisya na magkaroon ng crowd control at media blackout, katangahan! BOBONG PRESIDENTE!

  18. Uncle Pinoy · ·

    Good compilation, Bong. Your article shows that police incompetence is the norm in this country. I commented in another article that this is because our cops do not understand the nature of their job. On top of their ignorance, their woeful lack of training makes Manila’s Finest the world’s worst.

  19. San Diego dude · ·

    How it is done Hongkong way. Needed — well-trained cops with yag-bols.

  20. Hung Hang · ·

    Ito ang napapala ng mga hindot na mga fanatical yellow Pinoys na mga walang utak talaga sa pagboto ng isang low IQ at low EQ na presidente! Buong bayan at mamamayang Pilipino pati na mga OFW at mga nananahimik na sa ibang bansa damay pa rin sa kapapalpakan at kahihiyan ng mga naiwan sa Pinas. Kung pwede lang sanang magpapalit ng lahi! Tang-na talaga! Bwiset!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: